Tuesday, November 17, 2009

In Defense of Honest Discourse

I have a pet peeve. Okay. Fine. You got me. I have a kijillion pet peeves, but this one is pervasive. It bugs me on twitter, it bugs me in blogworld, it bugs me at preschool, it bugs me in casual discussion and in formal settings. It bugs me on Fox News and on CNN and on MSNBC. It bugs me on a train and in the rain and with a fox and in a freaking box.

Something becomes controversial, something goes down, something needs to be decided. It could small, like whether to mop or swiffer the preschool floor (no, I will never let that one die, it was too awesome). It could be huge like how to address health care issues in a nation of 360 million. It could seem petty like whether someone lied on their blog or it could be completely legitimate.

A discussion commences, it moves forward, sometimes it rages. Maybe it gets heated. Maybe it's gone on for an hour, for months, for an entire election cycle. Eventually, it never fails, large or small, some person starts using this tactic to shut others down. On twitter, it's the "it's over" syndrome. "Move on." "Drop the drama." At the board meeting, it might manifest as impatience. At the national level, maybe the dissenters are called out for "standing in the way of progress," or "failing to support our President," or worst of all in my opinion, racism. Maybe it's just the brilliant political quip "you lost, let it go." Yes, that was sarcasm.

There are hundreds of ways to say it, high-brow or blunt, but the core sentiment is this. We, "the in-the-right, cool people" are so OVER this and you the "still discussing a dead issue not cool people" are SO YESTERDAY. I believe its simplest expression may be the exaggerated eye roll. Which I've perfected, so I get it. Really. I even encourage it, just at home, not during the debate. That whole thing your mother taught you about not talking behind people's backs? It's kind of wrong. When mocking people for their passionate opinions, do it behind their backs. I don't mind being mocked, I just don't want to know about it.

I am not defending hate speech at any layer of our lives. I'm not saying we have to let nastiness continue on twitter, or on the House floor or at a community meeting.

What I am saying is this: It is belittling and counterproductive to tell people when something is "TOTALLY O-VAH." Because, to them, it's not. Letting discussion play through to its conclusion is so healthy. If it's done right, it often allows participants to let something go, to process, digest and understand the other point of view. It always allows a person to listen better to the opposition if they feel heard themselves. Shutting people down might feel like a win, but if you've left them seething and resentful, it's a loss in the end.

It particularly bothers me when there is a power differential. I see this on twitter all the time. Something will get heated and suddenly a blogger with lots of followers will start in on the embarrassment tactics. "This is over. Move on." I'm not saying we can't call someone out for getting personal. I do think that there's a better way. How about "that's really personal, can you keep it respectful" or "let's stick to the issue, not the person."

Because discourse leads to compromise and resolution. What if the founders, instead of hashing out the beautiful compromise we call the Constitution, had yelled IT'S OVER ASSHOLE and gone home? What if Ben had been all "I'm done discussing State's rights, bitches, we need FEDERALISM" and George had gotten in his face and said, "SMALL STATES RULE, WIGHEAD," and the Adams brothers had rolled their eyes and let fly with the "Let's just MOVE ON already, do we really need TWO houses in this stupid government. Blah, blah checks and balances, you people never shut up."

No, I am not comparing the constitutional convention debates to a twitter drama flare up or a preschool kerfluffle. Much. I am comparing them to the current national debates about the economy and health care.

I've been in discussions that went on for hours, but ended with unanimous votes. I've been in negotiations that tanked because people refused to stick it out. To hear others. I think great things can be achieved when we let respectful discourse and negotiations continue as long as necessary. Whether it's peace in the middle east or peace in a marriage or how much to regulate the insurance industry or what's a healthy snack to serve to four-year-olds or how much disclosure is necessary when you blog about products, whatever the issue, it can benefit from honest, respectful discussion.

And if you get to that point we all reach, where you are just done and you want your fleece pajamas and a glass of wine already, it's easy to achieve. Walk away from the debate, whether that means standing up and saying good night or closing your computer. Sticking around to tell other people that they are done feels like bullying.

That's what I think. (Blush, clears throat, crickets chirp.) But, no one really cares what I think anyway because you are all SO O-VAH me.

I can't exactly get all "this is what I think about debate" on you and "discourse is good" and then close comments can I? Gentle. This is the kind of post that usually stays in my head or in the drafts except that posting every day is hellishly hard. What do you think? Or tell me one of your pet peeves. Unless it's "women who complain about what other people tweet on twitter." In that case, please, mock me behind my back in an IM conversation so that I can pretend that everyone likes me.

E&E Tally: 11377 words
Blog posts: 17/30

Monday, November 16, 2009

Is This Cheating?

I think this might be cheating.

That was all I was going to type because it's almost 10:30 at night and I just finished writing my extra words for today, trying to make up for yesterday. And then, at 10:26 p.m. Nater rolled over for the first time. From his tummy to his back. I wasn't really watching. He was doing some tummy time on his yellow, little chick blanket. He rolled half way onto his side with kind of a clunk. I heard Matt say, "Your big noggin is in the way. It's like a kickstand." I looked up in time to see Matt adjust the baby's head a little and over he went.

In celebration, Matt put Nate's little butt in his hands and raised him up and down a few times in imitation of the world's smallest demon drop ride. Nate loves that. He's still giggling.

A million tiny moments add up to a life. So many of mine are priceless in their own quiet way. Have I mentioned lately how lucky I am?

10:39 p.m. Goodnight.
I'm closing my comments for most of the month of November while I participate in National Novel Writing Month and National Blog Posting Month. I can't ask you to talk to me every freaking day for thirty days. That's cruel and usual punishment. My email is always open - anymommyoutthere@gmail.com.


E&E Tally: 10011 words (Did you know that the average romance novel has between 50,000 and 100,000 words. That's a lot of words.)
Blog posts: 16/30

Sunday, November 15, 2009

Private Gee

If you take your little Opie lookalike

to a barber across from a large military installation, should you really be surprised when he emerges looking like a fresh recruit?



No. You should not. You should just put your tail between your legs and remember that just because everything is cheaper at Wal.Mart, it does not mean that you should do everything there.

He looks so grown up. It's killing me. I am dying here. Matt and I are going on a date so that I can drown my sorrows in cheap Thai food.

He's still adorable.


Him too. Yep. That's the same chair. He likes it, okay? He knows how to bounce by pumping both legs.


I'm closing my comments for most of the month of November while I participate in National Novel Writing Month and National Blog Posting Month. I can't ask you to talk to me every freaking day for thirty days. That's cruel and usual punishment. My email is always open - anymommyoutthere@gmail.com.


E&E Tally: 8414 words (Boo. I'm going to try to change this when we get home.)
Blog posts: 15/30

Saturday, November 14, 2009

Delightful

I babble about attachment here all the time. I always wonder if it makes sense to anyone that hasn't been through adoption/adoption therapy or struggled to attach to a child. Most of you are parents, so I will guess you understand attachment on an intuitive level. You certainly have seen your child light up when he sees you and fall apart when you leave the room at some stage in their development. The physical manifestations of secure attachment, you know.

I have read so much about attachment and bonding, attachment theory and attachment therapy over the last four years. I know a lot, relatively speaking, about unattached children and forming attachments with children after infancy. In my mind, attachment is the formal word for the building blocks of love, trust and security that we give our children by responding to their needs.

I had a chance to hear Dr. Kent Hoffman speak on attachment theory as a part of a training course for a volunteer program. Dr Hoffman is an attachment specialist who practices right here in our town. He runs a program designed to help at risk mothers form secure bonds with their babies.

Dr. Hoffman approached attachment from a different angle. He spoke about the types of attachment infants form with their biological (or original) caregivers, in order to make us understand that the young women he sees grew up in homes with a very poor attachment model. They have formed mostly disorganized attachments, which result, not necessarily from abusive caregivers, but from chaotic caregivers. Alcoholics and drug addicts often form disorganized attachments with their children. They aren't there fully, they don't meet all of their babies needs. They don't interact with their babies the way the baby craves. A severely depressed mom can form a disorganized attachment with her child.

A baby that forms a secure attachment to his parents learns, usually in the first six months of life, to view the world a certain way. He learns that life is fundamentally good and people are trustworthy. He expects his needs to be met. He learns that good things usually follow bad things and he can weather the bad. He learns that the world is inherently orderly and he can rely on people to help him.

A baby that forms a disorganized attachment lives in a different, far scarier world. She considers life fundamentally bad and uncertain and finds people untrustworthy. She expects that her needs will not be met. She learns that bad things keep happening for no reason in a random and chaotic pattern. She learns that the world is inherently chaotic and that she can not rely on anyone to help her. She may even learn that she can not rely on herself. She may learn that she can rely on only herself.

As teens and even adults, these people can't think ahead. They have no concept of a future that is different from their difficult today. They don't expect others to do what they say they will do. They expect relationships to be unpredictable and temporary and they expect to be hurt by the people that they need.

You see the difference? You see where in our society the second type of people often end up? Why some people can't seem to hold a job? Follow through? Take help that is offered? Even when it seems so obvious that it is right there.

Dr. Hoffman said a few things that will stick with me. I mean really stick with me. I wake up each morning thinking about how to incorporate these lessons into my life. I take a deep breath and remind myself to keep these things in mind for this new day.

Each person walks around with more pain than you imagine. I don't take this to mean that we are all doomed to suffering or eternal unhappiness, but just the fact of it rings true. We all have our sorrows. We all have our griefs. We are all struggling in some respect, somehow. We might be happy, functional, balanced. We might be depressed. We might be right where we need to be. We still all have our hidden pain.

We all want to be held by someone bigger, stronger, wiser and kinder than we are. It's right again, don't you think? I think we are all searching for this to a certain extent. Dr. Hoffman called this need the need to be in a held environment. I think you could say it's the universal human need to be safe, to feel secure and to feel loved. It's the "father-figure" many women yearn for, the "mentor" we all seek, the ultimate definition of god. As it pertains to raising children, I am quite certain I have "bigger and stronger" down. I need to keep working on the "wiser and kinder" aspect of the thing.

Every person yearns to be delighted in. This is my favorite. Every person yearns to be delighted in. I don't have "god" moments and "aha" moments are so Oprah-esque, but I got a chill. I knew I needed to hear this and live it. Every person yearns to be delighted in.

It's true for me. I instantly recognized exactly why I love this blog. People share my delight here, they delight in me and with me and I can reciprocate, visiting their thoughts delighting in and with them. It's also why we love certain friends. Don't you have a friend like that, a friend who delights in you? I'm lucky enough to have a few. Think about how it makes you feel. I've also had that friend who only wants to be delighted in and has little to offer me in return. Not so fun.

Mothers naturally delight in their babies in the first months of life. Look at this picture of me and Nate. (Artistic credit to the amazing Nick Follger.)

Can you see it? Can you see the basis of self-esteem? The idea that he is worth something? The security that comes from being in a held environment? We all give this to our babies, usually it comes by instinct, so naturally that you don't even notice.

The thing is, it's easy with a baby. Nature sets it up to be easy. The tininess. The helplessness. The smiles. The coos. The urge to protect and nurture. It gets harder in my limited experience. I have days when I absolutely know that I have not delighted in my four-year-olds. They are so far from delightful I might venture to use the word demonic. They are trying, whiny and disrespectful. I am exhausted, angry, exasperated. Some days, it's hard to find any delight.

They still need it. I know it because it clicked inside of me that on the days that go the worst, this is what is missing and I am the catalyst for change. The knowledge clicked that someone showing delight in me can turn my day, my mood, my path around.

I'm trying to let my children see me delight in them, to focus on showing them deliberately how they delight me. Oh, hell yes, I know, I still have dark days. I forget. I get off track. I'm still able to view the entire world and everything in it through my sarcastic lens. But somehow this idea of delighting in others has stuck in my brain, jived with all my hard won attachment knowledge, settled in to stay. I'm glad. I think, to go all biblical on you, that delight begats delight. It's one of those things that pays you back in orders of magnitude over what you give and pays others forward in a boundless stream of energy.

How delightful is that?

Help me? How do you show your children, especially your older out of infancy and toddler stage children that you find them delightful? How do you remember to find them delightful, you know, on the hard days?

(In case anyone was to mistake me for an expert on pretty much anything: I'm not. This whole post is my brain's interpretation of my adoption attachment research melded with my thoughts on the presentation of a true expert. Also, if you are thinking, wow, Stacey, that's weird. I don't have any issues showing my kids how delightful they are. They are always delightful and my delight beams from my eye sockets and my ears and other orifices of my body. Fabulous. I'm happy for you. I mean that. Just lie to me in the comments, Pollyanna, because the truth will make me all insecure and depressed and I am trying really hard for delighted here ;-)

E&E Tally: 8414 words
Blog posts: 14/30

Friday, November 13, 2009

First Snow

Some things never fail to feel magical. White twinkle lights. A lighted birthday cake in a dark room. That first glimpse of the tree on Christmas morning. A bonfire on the beach. Colored leaves swirling in the air. Your first underwater glimpse of a coral reef. When the groom sees the bride.

The first snow of the season is on this list.



For five glorious minutes or so every year, I see the magic. I'm able to push aside the damp, heavy blanket of experience. To forget that it means months of freezing cold. Slush. Frozen hands scraping the car. Day after day when we can't go out because the van lacks four-wheel drive. Our permanently chilly house. That feeling each morning that I have to force myself, physically force myself, to crawl out and hit the icy floor and pull on clothes so that I don't stay in my long underwear with a hat pulled down over my ears all winter. The effort it takes not to spend day after dark weary day alone in the house grousing and sniping at each other. Play dates must be carefully arranged, no more skipping to the park and running idly into friends.

The brief northern summer has spoiled us, played with our emotions, kissed us on the cheek and departed. There's nothing now until May but longing.

I detest winter. I am always cold. My blood grows sluggish in protest. My skin turns to unpleasant scales. My nose runs. When the big, wet crystal flakes started to fall this afternoon, I focused on the squeals of joy. I let them loose to wonder and stomp and catch it on their tongues. I even grabbed my camera and braved the wind, let them laugh at the white dust in my hair.

During quiet time, while Cue napped, I reverted to my Grinch-ish nature and glared out the window in disgust as it started to stick. He woke at 3:30. The light had already changed, short day fading into black night. He's too big, but I carried him down the stairs anyway. It's the only time of day that he is cuddly and pliant in my arms. He gasped on the landing, twisted to see over my shoulder out of the big double window. I felt the bitter draft pouring through the single pane. He saw the magic of the uninterrupted new snow.

"No, momma," he pointed, "no outside." I stopped to look with him, to hold him while he marveled, his runny red nosed pressed to the freezing glass. "No on da trees. No on da car. No on mine ball! Momma! No on mine ball!!"

"Yes, I see it, baby, I see the snow."

"No on mine ball!!"

"Uh huh. Snow on your ball. It's everywhere, isn't it?"

"No eveywhere." His excitement made him hard to hold. He lurched to the side. He wanted down to run to the door, to find his sister and brother, to share the wonder. I pointed out mundane things transformed for long minutes more, holding him close, wanting to see the magic through his eyes a little longer.



I'm closing my comments for most of the month of November while I participate in National Novel Writing Month and National Blog Posting Month. I can't ask you to talk to me every freaking day for thirty days. That's cruel and usual punishment. My email is always open - anymommyoutthere@gmail.com.


E&E Tally: 7404 words (This is so hard.)
Blog posts: 13/30 (My library books are overdue.)

Thursday, November 12, 2009

Natty Pants

It was bound to happen at some point and today is the day. I got behind. Actually, I stayed up way too late drinking wine and eating soup (that I made) and chatting with friends who keep me sane and keep me going and make this time one of the happiest times of my life.

I didn't write a blog post and I didn't write my 500 words. So, here it is. The blog of shame. I give you: the Natty Pants. A few people asked. I believe they meant on the cutey cute baby and I would love to oblige, but the cutey cute baby went to bed an hour ago. I only have 48 minutes before I miss a day of blogging and, therefore, the natty pants stand alone. Lie down alone. Or with my toaster and the left over Halloween candy.




I know. Pathetic. This is why people should not blog every day. They are damn cute pants though, admit it.

I'm closing my comments for most of the month of November while I participate in National Novel Writing Month and National Blog Posting Month. I can't ask you to talk to me every freaking day for thirty days. That's cruel and usual punishment. My email is always open - anymommyoutthere@gmail.com.


E&E Tally: 6764 words (boo)
Blog posts: 12/30 (sort of)

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Pants Required

At the risk of irritating Backpacking Dad, who has a complicated argument about feminism that requires me not to mock my husband, I am about to mercilessly mock my husband. In my defense it's not just for a cheap laugh or because I want to paint him as the stereotypical incompetent, buffoon father. It's because that's what we do. That's our marriage. We mock each other mercilessly. I was brought up to equate teasing to the point of pain with love. It works for us.

He mocks me because I can't boil water without burning something. I mock him because he can't cook anything without destroying the entire kitchen and possibly creating the need for a counter poultice. He mocks me because after five hours, an entire winter's supply of newspaper, two fire starter logs and a lot of cursing, I can't get our damn wood stove burning. I mock him for having the skill set of Pa Ingalls. Seriously, if the apocalypse occurs, we are golden.

He's an incredible parent. He is patient, kind and every bit if not more competent than I am. He spent the entire day on Tuesday first at Nate's well baby check up and then driving around to various clinics tracking down H1N1 vaccines for Ess and Gee and Cue. My point being, this post is not about gender stereotypes, it's not perpetuating the image of Dad as floundering, unnurturing and intentionally flummoxed by the role of caregiver. Matt handles three toddlers and a newborn with ease.

It's about pants.

In particular, an adorable pair of pants in which I dressed Nate on Tuesday morning before I sent him off to the pediatrician with his father. Believe me, I get that dressing babies and toddlers in clothes that you care about is silly - but it still happens. Sometimes, things are so cute that I can't resist. Sometimes, a grandma or an aunt sends something beyond adorable. In this case, a friend sent me this absolutely ridiculous pair of natty, frat boy, J-crewy patchwork pants with a tiny blue belt in size three-month and oh my god I love them.

So, I dressed my baby all frat-boy cutie and sent him off with Matt for measurements and shots and stuff. I took Cue to toddler class. Matt dropped the baby off with me after the appointment and we traded cars so that Matt could pick up Ess and Gee at preschool and take them to harass our health cooperative about flu vaccines.

He walked in the door with Nate in the car seat carrier tucked in sweetly under a knitted blanket. We conferred and kissed and swapped keys and off he went. I'm tempted to lie here and say that the baby was starving and I pulled him out to feed him. I didn't. I pulled him out to show off his natty pants. Except natty pants showing off = complete failure because he was not wearing said natty pants. He was not wearing ANY pants.

I suppose that was some kind of lesson that the universe attempted to teach me like: Do not take thy baby's pants in vain. Or: The baby is more important than the pants. Or: No one cares about how cute thou baby's pants are.

I didn't give a shit because where were his freaking pants? My favorite pants! Not on the baby's bottom half, that was clear.

That is Matt. He leaves the kids' stuff everywhere. No joke. We loose more hats, mittens, sweaters...pants. It makes my type-A, stuff-tracking, constant-inventory-taking head explode.

I thought about calling him, but I knew it would be an exercise in useless frustration.

Me: Where are the baby's pants?
Him: The baby's pants?
Me: The cute little patchwork pants? I put them on him this morning.
Him: ?

Instead, I swallowed my ire because I am an unbelievable martyr like that. I took my pantsless baby and my fully clothed toddler home and put them down for naps. I thought about calling him again and sending him back to the pediatrician for the pants, but fortunately I waited because I found them in the car.

The discovery of the pants would have made me feel bad for cursing his pant-loosing name all afternoon, but then he got back from the preschool pickup/vaccination of Ess and Gee and I cleaned out their lunch boxes. Gee's water bottle was not in his lunch box.

Tragedy of epic proportions. I had to endure Gee's mental breakdown over lack of water bottle all day today while Matt was safely and conveniently at work. With his lunch box and water bottle. And pants. I hope.

I don't ask for a lot. Okay, I ask for a lot and I'm asking for one more thing. Bring them home in their pants. Unless they've peed or shat on them and then throw them away with my blessing. (The pants. Throw the pants away, not our children.)

I'm closing my comments for most of the month of November while I participate in National Novel Writing Month and National Blog Posting Month. I can't ask you to talk to me every freaking day for thirty days. That's cruel and usual punishment. My email is always open - anymommyoutthere@gmail.com.


E&E Tally: 6764 words
Blog posts: 11/30