"
Difference of opinion," he shrieks at my feet, his face contorted into a mask of nearly-five-year-old rage and anguish.
"
DIFFERENCE OF OPINION!!"
I rub my eyes and press a tight, unhappy knot at the top of my neck. I'm tired. Hampton Noodle has Giardia. Take a minute to appreciate that sentence. Our massive dog, who does not use a toilet and is barely housetrained on a good day, has an intestinal parasite that causes the explosive shits. We've lost some carpets this week. We've lost considerable sleep to dog clean up and maintenance.
"That hurts my fe-e-e-elings," his sister chimes in, in what is perhaps the most irritating tone on the planet, the nearly-five-year-old-girl half-sob, half-whine of ear piercing mother brain death.
Even as I am, in part, its product, I roll my eyes at current popular parenting theory, at acknowledging and labeling feelings, at preschools that encourage long, drawn-out discussions of hurt feelings, at "positive" discipline. I don't want to have a forty-five minute discussion about why we are not having hot dogs for dinner and how that offends the temperamental sensibilities of the under five set in my domain. I. HAVE. RAVIOLI. IN. THE. FREEZER. PERIOD.
That's the kind of parent I am, honestly. The I-have-ravioli-in-the-freezer-period kind. Still, crushed hot dog dreams notwithstanding, I respect the need for children to have their feelings acknowledged. I understand the problem with repression in our culture. Most of all, I want my children to enjoy deep discussion and debate, to understand that argument is healthy and fun. I don't want to raise people that can't handle disagreement.
I taught them the phrase 'difference of opinion.' "It's just a difference of opinion," I say as they scream at each other in the back of the van about whether the lyrics to Rudolf the Rednose Reindeer are "it's a jelly story," or the more popular "he'll go down in history." "Different opinions are okay," I remind Gee when he sobs helplessly against my leg because Parker doesn't like the color blue and he does.
It's just a difference of opinion. We can all think differently on this. We don't have to scream at others until they agree with us. We can agree to disagree and still like each other, even love each other. I validate their feelings when I can. I know it's frustrating that your sister is singing words with which you disagree. I'm sorry time out hurts your feelings.
But, puh-lease. Do you see this oh great and powerful labeling and validation gurus? All this crap about letting them express their feelings and giving them words for situations, etc., etc. They gang up on my ass and use that shit against me. Whether of not we are having hot dogs for dinner is not a difference of opinion. It's an edict from on high. I am most definitely the "high" in this situation and I don't mean from the huge glass of wine that I'm about to pour before I boil the raviolis. I'm not interested in hurt feelings over dinner choice. In fact, the first answer that runs through my head and almost makes it out of my mouth is something like: "Good. Take your hurt feelings to bed. More ravioli for me."
Except.
Except. Do I want to dissuade them from questioning authority? Do I want to discourage them from asking for what they want? No. Sometimes? No? Are they independent, questioning souls or snotty, bratty children who want hot dogs for dinner? Is it too much to hope that I'll raise independent, questioning souls who are polite and non-bratty? I'll accept the snot.
"Gee," I begin over his hot dog induced howl. "Disagreement is respectful. You are whining and your behavior is not okay."
"But, I
WANT hot dogs for dinner."
"I heard you, but I am in charge of dinner, hot dogs are not good for our bodies every night, and I am making raviolis."
Ess moans again. "That hurts my heart." There is no drama like the drama of a nearly five year old girl scorned.
I raise my eyes to the heavens momentarily, so that they can't see my smile. "Your heart will recover. I could give you a hug."
They straggle to the basement, amid snivels of defeat, for a conciliatory viewing of bizarre animated robots. It's another hard lesson, I suppose. You can disagree with authority, you can tell authority respectfully how you feel, that you are hurt, that you are outraged, that they are wrong. Hopefully, if you are lucky, authority will acknowledge your feelings, but you won't very often change their position. I know it hurts, babies, but someday, you will have spent the prior evening drafting a letter to the city planning commission expressing your outrage and outlining the legal reasons why a parking lot is wrong and setting forth, in careful detail, your grievances, your loss of property value, your expectations under the current zoning laws and master city plan and someone will look down on your pain and say, "I have parking lots in my freezer." Or something along those lines.
The very next day, tired and raw and on edge, you will find a miraculous well of patience that you don't normally display for your children's outrage and railing against the dinner machine because you have been woefully and painfully reminded of what it feels like to suffer what is, to you, an extreme injustice, and to be told, "eh, sorry, difference of opinion."
Losing is hard. Difference of opinion helps you accept others, but it doesn't lessen the emotions. Sometimes, you want hot dogs and you don't get them and it's over. Sometimes, the edict is just plain wrong and you have to rage against it until you achieve change or you die trying.
I don't know if I'm even coming close to teaching my children how to walk these lines. All I've learned from life and from parenting is that being the authority is hard too. That and that occasionally, after reflection, there's a way to soften the loss. Like, maybe chocolate ice cream after the ravioli. It's not hot dogs, but it's something.